Introduction to EHR Interoperability
The digital transformation of healthcare has revolutionized how medical information flows between systems, providers, and patients. Patient portals, patient engagement systems, advanced telehealth solutions, remote health monitoring systems, and EMR systems are among the most prevalent digitally powered healthcare systems. The interoperability of all these applications ensures seamless information flow and connects the entire health system.
Why EHR Interoperability Matters More Than Ever
The interconnectivity of these solutions with EHR systems is particularly important given their potential to transform patient care delivery. However, connecting solutions with electronic health records software and guiding successful system rollouts remains challenging, highlighting the ongoing lack of EHR interoperability that continues to plague healthcare organizations worldwide.
Today, medical practices acknowledge the importance and value of interoperability solutions in healthcare and are rapidly adopting these solutions, especially EHR interoperability systems. By 2025, the worldwide digital healthcare market is expected to reach $500 billion. According to MarketsandMarkets reports, the global market for healthcare interoperability solutions is predicted to reach $4.2 billion by 2024, up from $2.3 billion in 2019.
Despite these advantages, EHR interoperability in healthcare remains difficult to implement. Health-tech professionals struggle to manage PHI and the variety of EHR systems. Furthermore, concerns about personal information privacy and data system security persist. Data protection and confidentiality are being addressed through new and more secure technologies such as healthcare cloud computing and blockchain.
This comprehensive guide focuses on EHR interoperability solutions and highlights the need and scope of these solutions in today's clinical ecosystem. We'll explore evidence-based strategies to improve and measure EHR interoperability technology solutions within current standards and frameworks.
Understanding Healthcare Interoperability
The Critical Challenge of Healthcare Data Exchange
Healthcare data has always been difficult to capture, manage, and exchange securely across different platforms and among clinicians. The nature of health data creates a paradox: it's difficult to share because it's sensitive and requires high privacy and security, but being unable to access it when needed most generally leads to considerable harm for patients and providers.
The Real Cost of Poor Interoperability
The lack of healthcare interoperability can lead to an inadequate understanding of an individual's or population's health needs, resulting in negative clinical outcomes and higher expenses that burden both healthcare systems and patients.
Interoperability solutions have been a hot topic in healthcare for over a decade. The passage of the HITECH Act in 2009 marked a watershed moment when healthcare staff were strongly encouraged to adopt EHRs instead of paper-based records. With increased EHR usage, secure data transmission became a major concern due to the lack of interoperability between healthcare solutions.
Defining Healthcare Interoperability
Interoperability is most simply defined as the ability of software, information systems, and devices to link and integrate within and outside the limits of healthcare organizations to ease access and exchange of patient data for addressing health challenges in general.
Why Interoperability Is More Critical Than Ever
Interoperability and data exchange are increasingly important for delivering effective healthcare, as populations worldwide are aging and people want to live longer. The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality estimates that two out of every three older Americans have at least two chronic behavioral or physical illnesses. Treatment for patients with multiple chronic illnesses currently accounts for approximately 66% of all healthcare costs in the United States.
Current State of EHR Adoption and Integration
According to the Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC), the use of electronic health records has expanded considerably in the United States. Although many hospitals now routinely receive medical records and patient data from external providers, less than half integrate the data they receive into individual patient records.
While access to critical clinical data has increased, much more effort is required to bring stakeholders together to develop an integrated data ecosystem that truly serves patients and providers.
The Business Case for Interoperability
Today, health data interoperability benefits companies throughout the healthcare industry by providing physicians and other healthcare practitioners with a complete picture of their patients' health status. Health plans could better understand utilization rates and service demand if health information systems were more interconnected. Government service providers would be able to access demographic data to identify trends and meet citizens' needs. Life science companies could use large databases to conduct faster and more informed research.
With improved interoperability, organizations could stop seeing individuals as patients one day, health plan members the next, and health app users after that. Instead, decision-makers across the healthcare sector would be able to look at how users access and use health information, independent of its source, to create better care models, improve patient safety, and enhance experiences for those they serve.
The Four Levels of EHR Interoperability
According to the Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society, interoperability solutions in healthcare can be categorized into four distinct levels, each building upon the previous to create increasingly sophisticated data exchange capabilities:
Level 1: Foundational Interoperability
At the foundational level, health systems establish the interconnectivity standards required for one system or application to properly communicate data. Easy and seamless transfer of clinical data from a health system to a user or another platform represents the lowest level of interoperability.
Key Characteristics:
- Clinical data is securely sent from one system or device to another without being interpreted or formatted
- The information shared with the user or receiver platform doesn't need interpretation
- Basic data transmission without structural requirements
Real-World Examples:
- A nurse manually inserting information from a PDF file containing a patient's most recent lab results into the patient's health record
- When a patient gets discharged from the hospital, the health summary they receive in PDF format
Level 2: Structural Interoperability
Structural interoperability in healthcare specifies the organization and formatting of data transfer, including how data fields are interpreted. When structural interoperability, or structured transmission, is established, all data is standardized to a precise format so diverse systems or devices can interpret it.
Advanced Features:
- Data is organized in a specific manner to allow the receiving system to automatically detect specific data fields
- Due to structural interoperability provided by data standards like FHIR and HL7, medical records can be consistent, aggregated, and readily moved between systems
- Both sending and receiving systems must follow accepted data standards to ensure structural interoperability
Perfect Example: E-prescriptions demonstrate this level of interoperability by maintaining consistent data structure across different pharmacy and provider systems.
Level 3: Semantic Interoperability
Semantic interoperability provides common models and codification of data that allows the usage of data elements with well-defined meanings from widely accessible value sets and coding vocabularies, offering users shared understanding and meaning.
Technical Capabilities:
- Data interchange across systems with radically different data structures occurs at the semantic level
- Sometimes called 'semantic transport' due to its advanced data interpretation abilities
- Imaging systems, which handle several specialized DICOM and non-DICOM picture formats, provide an obvious example
Clinical Benefits: Semantic interoperability allows images to be transferred, interpreted, and incorporated between multiple systems regardless of their original format or source. However, as systems offer the same information in various ways, determining what data to acquire and convey can be difficult. Some experts believe that artificial intelligence will be required to achieve comprehensive semantic interoperability.
This level allows providers to share patient health data with other healthcare providers using different EHR software seamlessly.
Level 4: Organizational Interoperability
This level of interoperability, added in March 2019, is increasingly popular in the healthcare landscape. Organizational or Level 4 interoperability factors include governance, policy, social, legal, and administrative issues to facilitate safe, frictionless, and timely data exchange and utilization within and between companies, entities, and people.
Comprehensive Integration:
- These components enable integrated, shared, and trust-based end-user procedures and workflows
- Organizational interoperability refers to seamless data flow between multiple organizations with different criteria, policies, and goals
- At this level, governance, policy, and technology innovations ensure integrated workflows, security, and consent among a diverse set of healthcare stakeholders
Some experts believe that organizational interoperability, rather than semantic interoperability, represents the highest and most complex level in healthcare data exchange.
Market Scope and Growth Opportunities
Explosive Market Growth Projections
According to a Research and Markets report, the projected value of the healthcare interoperability solutions market by 2026 is estimated to be $5.7 billion. Despite multiple challenges, EHR interoperability is rapidly expanding, and experts believe that EHR/EMR interoperability will become more advanced in the coming years.
Investment in Interoperability Expertise
A study conducted by Deloitte revealed that 80 out of 100 technology executives have hired data architects to define their interoperability strategies, indicating that the scope of EHR interoperability technology solutions is flourishing and attracting significant corporate investment.
Future Vision: The 2040 Healthcare Data Ecosystem
According to EHR interoperability principles, all patient data, including health and well-being information, will be interconnected and available for action and research. Another Deloitte report reveals that health data streams will converge by 2040, resulting in a highly tailored and comprehensive view of each patient's health.
This transformation shows that EHR interoperability will leverage clinical decision-making and boost patient outcomes through unprecedented data accessibility and integration.
Proven Strategies to Improve EHR Interoperability
Addressing Core Barriers
Addressing cost, consistency, security, and scalability issues is primary for improving EHR interoperability. These barriers are stagnating EHR capabilities, and providers fail to achieve interoperability. To ensure interoperability, providers must consider specific technologies and strategies to overcome these barriers and facilitate seamless data flow across different health systems, organizations, and entities.
Expert Consensus: Leading healthcare technology experts believe that cloud computing and blockchain can effectively enable full-scale interoperability and overcome communication roadblocks.
Strategy 1: Adopting Cloud Technology
The Cloud Migration Advantage
EHR cloud migration is in high demand currently. Cloud EHR deployment reduces hefty costs that healthcare providers must bear by providing a pay-as-you-go strategy that scales with organizational needs.
Enhanced Security Benefits:
- The cloud environment helps healthcare providers alleviate some security burdens
- Most cloud EHR companies provide round-the-clock support and specialized cybersecurity services to keep PHI secure
- Data sources like clinical, lab, and pharmacy systems can readily integrate and access cloud-based EHRs, ensuring interoperability across all health systems and entities while enhancing patient care quality
Operational Advantages: Cloud-based EHRs allow users to store data on multiple servers in different geographical regions, making it simple to save and retrieve data as needed. They include advanced security features that protect data from hackers or unauthorized access.
Important Consideration: These benefits are limited to public and hybrid clouds. If providers create and deploy EHRs on private clouds, it could be expensive and require a professional in-house IT team.
Strategy 2: Leveraging Blockchain EHR Technology
Revolutionary Data Security
Blockchain technology is a decentralized, public digital ledger that permanently and verifiably records transactions. Blockchains are inherently resistant to data manipulation and modification by design, making them ideal for healthcare applications.
Interoperability Benefits:
- Increases EHR interoperability by allowing users/patients to share their medical records with healthcare providers via a secure, private blockchain network as requested by the provider
- Blockchain has unique security characteristics, such as creating audit trails, to reduce the risk of data loss from malicious actors
- Has the potential to improve semantic interoperability significantly
Cost-Effective Implementation: Developing costly interfaces across different EHR systems using blockchain is unnecessary—just a private key is required to access patient records. This may allow any healthcare professional from any location to view health records with the correct credentials.
Patient Empowerment: Patients using blockchain EHR become full masters of their data, which may increase patient involvement. They provide clinicians with access to their health information, not vice versa.
Strategy 3: Healthcare APIs (Application Programming Interfaces)
The Universal Interoperability Solution
The most common method for achieving interoperability is through open Application Programming Interfaces (APIs). Data and protected health information (PHI) can be shared and transmitted between EHRs and health information technology systems through APIs, enabling easy communication between disparate applications and health systems.
Organizational Benefits:
- APIs make internal and cross-organizational software interoperability easier for healthcare providers
- They promote shorter deployment times and offer easy access to medical data, lab results, and other information for patients
- FHIR APIs will be integrated into all healthcare platforms soon, establishing consistent standards for all systems and simplifying third-party integrations
Strategy 4: Artificial Intelligence Integration
AI-Powered Interoperability Solutions
Artificial Intelligence, today's fastest-growing technology, is also one of the most promising ways to improve EHR interoperability. Thanks to machine learning capabilities at the core of AI systems, it can process large volumes of data such as patient forms, clinical notes, and health records with unprecedented speed and accuracy.
Scalability Solutions:
- Scalability issues in EHR and other data-related interoperability concerns can be easily addressed with AI technology
- AI systems integrated into EHR software offer crucial and current insights, regardless of their data sources
- These insights facilitate clinical decision-making to ensure better patient outcomes through data-driven approaches
Future Outlook and Trends
The Path Forward: 2025-2040
With these four strategic approaches, improving EHR interoperability becomes more achievable for healthcare organizations of all sizes. Standardizing data entry will be critical for future interoperability in medical information systems.
Collaborative Standards Development
All stakeholders should collaborate to develop standards that make it easier to extract patient data, providing organizations with the most up-to-date and relevant information. Another step should be centralizing this data throughout the healthcare ecosystem to create truly integrated care delivery.
The Radical Interoperability Vision
2040 Healthcare Transformation
By 2040, every modern medical company may be required to embrace radical interoperability, meaning that every individual's unified health information will be accessible for research and therapeutic purposes so that clinical trials or CROs can directly access patient health records to leverage clinical studies.
Government Initiatives and Regulatory Support
The relevant US government initiatives aim to improve coordination and management, care quality, patient safety, and outcomes. They also aim to boost patient privacy and security, staff productivity, operational effectiveness, knowledge sharing, medical research, medical error rates, healthcare costs, and complete population health.
Technology Integration Requirements
New software systems will always need to communicate with one another effectively. Above all, APIs will enable interoperability and other critical advancements for practices as they seek to meet patient demand for accessing medical records, shift to value-based care, and fully utilize analytics for improved healthcare delivery.
Key Takeaways
Essential Points for Healthcare Leaders:
-
Market Growth: The healthcare interoperability market is projected to reach $5.7 billion by 2026, representing significant investment opportunities
-
Four-Level Framework: Understanding foundational, structural, semantic, and organizational interoperability levels is crucial for strategic planning
-
Technology Solutions: Cloud computing, blockchain, APIs, and AI represent the most promising approaches to achieving true interoperability
-
Patient-Centered Benefits: Improved interoperability leads to better patient outcomes, reduced costs, and enhanced care coordination
-
Future Readiness: Organizations must prepare for radical interoperability requirements by 2040 to remain competitive and compliant
Action Steps for Implementation:
- Assess your current interoperability level and identify gaps
- Invest in cloud-based EHR solutions with strong API capabilities
- Consider blockchain technology for enhanced security and patient control
- Integrate AI tools to handle large-scale data processing and analysis
- Collaborate with stakeholders to develop industry-wide standards
The future of healthcare depends on seamless data exchange, and organizations that invest in comprehensive interoperability solutions today will lead the transformation of patient care delivery tomorrow.